Giving Credit Where Credit is Due
"Go to work, and above all co-operate and don’t hold back on one another or try to gain at the expense of another. Any success in such lopsidedness will be increasingly short-lived. These are the synergetic rules that evolution is employing and trying to make clear to us. They are not man-made laws. They are the infinitely accommodative laws of the...universe." R. Buckminister Fuller, Operating Manual for Spaceship Earth, 1969
I met Matt in 1976. He had created Renascence Library and was teaching a course called Redesigning the Future. It was there that I was introduced to Buckminister Fuller by reading his book, Intuition. Matt had a long list of books, more than 500 that he believed necessary to read and understand if one was to successfully navigate the future and thrive well into the 21st Century. His course brought the contents of these books alive and always he gave credit and recognition to the authors and their bodies of knowledge. Some of the books explored ancient histories and others forecast futures. The list recognized every field and every religion. Some were fiction, others non-fiction.
While my field was education, I had come to know that as a teacher, I should be reading a vast variety of books outside of my field. Through the Learning Exchange, I was introducing teachers and children to a world of ideas and linking these ideas to their work, showing how ideas build upon each other. Nothing came from nothing, but rather through the assimilation of a collection of thoughts and ideas perturbing our minds and catalyze new ideas... perhaps higher order ideas. I take much joy in this reality.
So when Matt and I formed MG Taylor Corporation, we were careful to provide the genesis of our thinking... what was it that perturbed our minds to create our body of knowledge? We continued the 500 reading list, updating it as appropriate; we created models and methods, giving credit to the thoughts or work of others. In many ways what we created together was totally unique to anything else happening around design, collaboration, group genius, probable futures, and systems theory, yet we recognized these ideas were sparked from the thoughts and readings of others. What we bought to them was our unique way of seeing the universe and how we could effectively contribute to the creation of a healthier world. Our concepts were original and authentic enough to receive a patent for our work in 2001. More than twenty years had passed since the inception of MGT, and yet our body of knowledge was still original.
Today, more than 40 years have passed since we began our explorations, first separately and then together. Our ideas and work have mixed with other bodies of knowledge and spread throughout the world. We have educated and trained thousands of people, and many of these early students have trained hundreds of others. Many of these individuals have added to our body of knowledge and enriched it. Indeed, our work is succeeding in our original mission to change the way of working. This is goodness.
What disappoints me, however, are the growing number of practitioners who claim to be leaders in the knowledge economy. How can an individual or organization say they are doing knowledge work when they others work without giving credit where credit is due? This does a huge disservice to those they are "imparting" their knowledge to. They are simply providing information ... and the concepts cannot go deep and connect to an entire ecosystem of thought. The ideas cannot grow and take root and create lasting change. There is no knowledge or wisdom in this way of working. The ideas will not be sustainable.
Jonas Salk defined sustainable as "Are we being good ancestors?" Simple. It demands we ask ourselves to reach further into the past and the future than the moment of short-term profits. It is true that in a world of increasing mashups and Internet story circulation, it becomes more and more difficult to seek and recognize the history of ideas and give credit where credit is due. Take MagicWorks, for instance. I stumbled on this site and was disappointed that this site offered our body of knowledge as theirs. No where on the site was there an acknowledgement of our work. (NOTE: MagicWorks founders have since apologized and explained how and why they avoided recognizing MGT's body of knowledge and established a reference page to the MGT body of work.)
It is such a joy when people write or call and ask if they can reference a Journal page or some work from my body of knowledge. The simple request back is "Yes. Please tell me how you used it and the reactions from your participants or audience." Matt and I, individually and together, developed MGT to be transformative ... to provide synergies created through designing and crafting environments, processes, and tools to help shape a better, more just world. Buckminister Fuller says it correctly in the quote at the opening of this journal.
"Go to work, and above all co-operate and don’t hold back on one another or try to gain at the expense of another. Any success in such lopsidedness will be increasingly short-lived. These are the synergetic rules that evolution is employing and trying to make clear to us. They are not man-made laws. They are the infinitely accommodative laws of the...universe." R. Buckminister Fuller, Operating Manual for Spaceship Earth, 1969


Reader Comments (4)
It saddens me to feel Gail’s anger and frustration. I consider acting responsibly in our obligation to MG Taylor Corporation and to Matt and Gail personally not only the right thing to do but the only thing to do.
As a founding principle of The Value Web network, honoring this responsibility benefits us all, now and certainly in the future that concerns Gail. Matt and Gail are still encouraging us, teaching us, and surprising us.
We at the Value Web and others are lucky to know Gail as a co-designer, mentor and friend. Gail, I hope we make you proud.
Enjoying each others company is just a huge bonus!
maybe this is some kind of misunderstanding and we will write you a personal letter on this topic later this week.
Do you remember that we had lunch together with you and Matt on January 1 this year in Menlo Park? We told you everything about our plans to found MagicWorks and we asked you about your opinion, your patents and how we could use your methodology in the right way.
After all we felt encouraged by both of you to go ahead.
We really hope that we can smooth this out – we would really like to keep a good relationship to you and Matt and definitely don’t want to steal your ideas and life long work.
Nancy & Jens from MagicWorks
What I was totally unprepared for was seeing your website without any mention of MGT from which the genisus of your ideas and concepts had developed. And I was even more dismayed to see that you had enveloped yourself in an entire field of others who gave no appreciative recognition to MGT and the incredible body of knowledge it brings to the consulting world.
What is it about our conversation that gave you the feeling that we said, "Go ahead and take all you want without giving us credit?" In your mind, what created your right of passage into a world that does not give credit where credit is due?
It just saddens me that in a knowledge economy people think they can't afford or take the time to learn from whence the ideas came. Read my Journal page again and pay attention to the quote by Bucky. It is about authenticity and building trust through the generations of development.
What a joy TVW has been. I believe a wonderful synergy has emerged that allows us all to reach new peaks of learning and facilitating.
What I appreciate most about The Value Web is your persistence in getting it right. How do we credit Matt and Gail and MGT for what we have learned. How do we keep them engaged so that there is a great back and forth learning.
Creating a self-organizing system in the spirit of the MGT process is not easy nor cheap. There are no short cuts. The VW has invested itself as individuals and an organization in this learning and becoming.
The royalties that MGT gets is important to us and vital to the well-being of all, but it pales in comparison with the integrity you keep. It reminds me on a day to day basis that there is still honesty out there in this huge world of short term thinking and instant profits.
Thank you.